Interesting information

Advertisements

Review: “Human Capital vs. Signaling is Empirically Unresolvable” by Nick Huntington-Klein (CSU Fullerton, August 2018)

Public Access Peer Reviews for the Social Sciences

Read the working paper here.

Contact Nick Huntington-Klein here.

Is education a process by which individuals acquire useful skills, or one whereby individuals who already possess skills set themselves apart from others? In theory, the distinction between these two visions of the education process carry radically different implications for whether education is an enterprise worthy of public subsidy. While it’s hard to argue that either theory is completely false, much ink has been spilt in the tussle over whether one or the other predominates. Prior estimates of the proportion of returns to education attributable to signaling range from 10% to 80%.

In practice, argues Nick Huntington-Klein, these models are so difficult to disentangle from one another that there’s no point trying.

Huntington-Klein’s persuasive if somewhat depressing argument begins with a basic mediating variables framework: if there is a causal link between education and individual outcomes, signaling and human…

View original post 672 more words

Jason Brennan counters critics of ‘Markets Without Limits