Aeromagazine has a superb article that deals with twelve such arguments that are commonly heard.
While the whole thing is worth your time to read I wanted to extract two in particular.
First up is the classic one about shoutingfire!in a crowded theatre;
Answer: Anyone who says “you can’t shoutfire!in a crowded theatre” is showing that they don’t know much about the principles of free speech, or free speech law—or history.
This old canard, afavourite referenceof censorship apologists, needs to be retired. It’s repeatedly and inappropriately used to justify speech limitations. People have been using this cliché as if it had some legal meaning, while First Amendment lawyers roll their eyes and point out that it is, in fact, as Alan Dershowitz puts it, “a caricature of logical argumentation.”Ken White has already penned a brilliant and thorough takedown of this misconception. Please…
View original post 703 more words
Utopia, you are standing in it! 
Recent Comments