![]()
The tired Marxism of @chrishipkins MP. Is government provision cheaper because they don’t have to make a profit?
05 May 2015 1 Comment
in Austrian economics, entrepreneurship, Marxist economics, politics - New Zealand Tags: schools, state owned enterprises

At least one Labour MP must have watched the other channel when the Berlin Wall fell. How else could Chris Hipkins, MP ever think that government provision is cheaper because they don’t have to make a profit? OK, he was a teenager when the Berlin Wall fell, but even teenagers watch the headline news or pick up the gist of the headlines from friends.
The tidiest of all Marxist arguments, the saddest of all Marxist arguments is government operation of businesses is cheaper because they don’t have to make a profit. At least we were spared the cliché “people not profits”.
Leaving to one side that government school buildings are built by private contractors to the Ministry of Education, let’s focus on whether government businesses will be cheaper because they don’t have to make a profit.
No cheap shots about how the portfolio of state owned enterprises are worth $30 billion returned a profit of $20 million to New Zealand taxpayers last year or of the inherent flaws of government ownership:
On the free market, in short, the consumer is king, and any business firm that wants to make profits and avoid losses tries its best to serve the consumer as efficiently and at as low a cost as possible.
In a government operation, in contrast, everything changes. Inherent in all government operation is a grave and fatal split between service and payment, between the providing of a service and the payment for receiving it.
The government bureau does not get its income as does the private firm, from serving the consumer well or from consumer purchases of its products exceeding its costs of operation.
No, the government bureau acquires its income from mulcting the long-suffering taxpayer. Its operations therefore become inefficient, and costs zoom, since government bureaus need not worry about losses or bankruptcy; they can make up their losses by additional extractions from the public till.
The accounting profit or loss of any firm combines two rather different concepts of profit:
- normal profit – the interest paid to those who lend capital to the form either as a loan or as equity; and
- economic profit – the earnings that result from risk taking and entrepreneurship.
Normal profit is simply at the cost of raising capital from investors. This capital can be borrowed in the form of a loan or can be equity.
Chris Hipkins, MP concedes a need to borrow capital when he talks about government typically having lower costs to access capital in the screenshot above. Both private and public builders of schools will have to pay to access capital.
Economic profit is a far more complicated concept frequently misunderstood, especially by Marxists, the Left over Left and, of course, professional media commentators. As Mises explains:
If all people were to anticipate correctly the future state of the market, the entrepreneurs would neither earn any profits nor suffer any losses. They would have to buy the complementary factors of production at prices which would, already at the instant of the purchase, fully reflect the future prices of the products. No room would be left either for profit or for loss.
What makes profit emerge is the fact that the entrepreneur who judges the future prices of the products more correctly than other people do buys some or all of the factors of production at prices which, seen from the point of view of the future state of the market, are too low. Thus the total costs of production — including interest on the capital invested — lag behind the prices which the entrepreneur receives for the product. This difference is entrepreneurial profit.
Profits arise from the dynamism of the market and the ability of superior entrepreneur’s to anticipate the future better than others for which there is always only a temporary profit:
Profits are never normal. They appear only where there is a maladjustment, a divergence between actual production and production as it should be in order to utilize the available material and mental resources for the best possible satisfaction of the wishes of the public. They are the prize of those who remove this maladjustment; they disappear as soon as the maladjustment is entirely removed.
Frank Knight in Risk, Uncertainty, and Profit (1921) distinguished between interest on capital that is lend as either a loan or equity – long-run normal profits – and the short-run profits and losses earned by superior, or suffered by inferior entrepreneurs , respectively. This entrepreneurial superiority or inferiority flows from the ability to forecast the uncertain future. Those entrepreneurs “with superior knowledge and superior foresight,” wrote Frank Fetter, “are merchants, buying when they can in a cheaper and selling in a dearer capitalisation market, acting as the equalizers of rates and prices.”
Knight argued that entrepreneurs earn profits as a return for putting up with uncertainty and anticipating uncertainty faster than the rest. Many businesses are unprofitable because of rising costs or falling sales that were not anticipated. The Knightian concept is of the profit-seeking entrepreneur investing resources under uncertainty about market demand and costs in the future.
Alchian (1950) illustrated the unreliability of cost estimation with the range of bids made in government tendering processes. When contractors bid for the same project, these entrepreneurs routinely disagree over its likely cost by margins of 20 percent. These tenderers are predicting their own costs, about which they are knowledgeable, and they have an incentive to be truthful to win the initial tender.
Profits and losses, by rewarding and penalising the entrepreneurs who are not the quickest, ensures that only what consumers want is bought to the market as Henry Hazlett explains:
In a free economy, in which wages, costs, and prices are left to the free play of the competitive market, the prospect of profits decides what articles will be made, and in what quantities—and what articles will not be made at all.
If there is no profit in making an article, it is a sign that the labour and capital devoted to its production are misdirected: the value of the resources that must be used up in making the article is greater than the value of the article itself.
Profits arise as the reward for superior foresight into the future and innovation. Both of these concepts are not associated with government run businesses as Alfred Marshall explained:
A government could print a good edition of Shakespeare’s works, but it could not get them written.
As for Hipkins’ argument that governments can borrow at a cheaper rate than private firms, Bailey and Jensen (1972) said:
…we argue that efficient allocation of risk bearing is usually more difficult for government projects than it is for private ones. Therefore, if anything, the allowance for risk should be greater for government projects than it is for otherwise comparable private ones…
We find no support for the arguments in favor of using the government bond rate or any other such universally low rate for discounting costs and benefits of public projects.
We concur in Hirshleifer’s conclusion that a public project with given attributes (in terms of dispersion of possible future outcomes and of the covariance of these outcomes with those for existing portfolios) should he discounted with at least as high a rate as a similar private project.
This “same rate” should include the appropriate allowances for taxes and other distortions in private markets (as outlined by Harberger) as well as the appropriate allowances for risk, which we have outlined above.
Moreover, if private markets in risk are as “imperfect” as many have claimed, that merely tends to increase the rate that should be used, because the government is even less able to distribute risks than are these markets.
Penn and Teller on recycling – the practice of ‘feeling good for no reason’ | Carpe Diem Blog
05 May 2015 Leave a comment
Down and out in NZ = social housing with fast broadband
02 May 2015 Leave a comment
in economics of regulation, politics - New Zealand, poverty and inequality, urban economics
The Dominion Post had a front page story yesterday about an 80-year-old pensioner required to pay for fast broadband in her new social housing. Her new apartment happens to be in my same suburb. I can see the new apartments from my window as I type.

She didn’t have much use for this fast broadband, which cost an extra $20 a month, because she is legally blind. She cannot have a landline-only option because of the way her apartment is wired and the way in which fast broadband works.
The 27 flats have been fitted with fibre-optic cabling, and residents, many of whom are pensioners or have disabilities, cannot opt for a landline-only service.
National building standards require new apartments to be wired with fast broadband. A classic example of the inability of central planning to deal with the diversity of preferences and incomes.
In this case, the victim of central planning it is an old age pensioners obviously in poor circumstances as well as legally blind who is out of pocket. She is one of a number of old age pensioners who are similarly out-of-pocket when they living on a strictly limited budget.

New Zealand and US real housing prices, 1975 – 2014
01 May 2015 Leave a comment
in economics of regulation, politics - New Zealand, urban economics
The RMA is the Resource Management Act and was passed just before New Zealand housing prices started to rise rapidly. Was this introduction of much stronger restrictions on the supply of land, followed by a 20 year long rise in the price of land housing more than a coincidence?

Source: Dallas Fed; Housing prices deflated by personal consumption expenditure (PCE) deflator.
Who pays the highest income tax rate?
01 May 2015 Leave a comment
in politics - Australia, politics - New Zealand, politics - USA, public economics Tags: average tax rates, Marginal tax rates, vaccination and the labour supply
Highest income #tax rate among #OECD countries? Belgium with 42.8% statista.com/chart/3337/whe… http://t.co/RgaWxsGPzB—
Statista (@StatistaCharts) March 25, 2015
The Left over Left is withering away
30 Apr 2015 Leave a comment
in politics - Australia, politics - New Zealand, politics - USA Tags: voter demographics
@NZGreen hypocrisy on trade ties with Cuba and Saudi Arabia – J’accuse, J’accuse
29 Apr 2015 Leave a comment
in development economics, growth disasters, Marxist economics, politics - New Zealand
The Greens in Parliament yesterday were making great play of the fact that New Zealand is willing to conclude a trade agreement with Saudi Arabia, but not with ISIS, despite the fact that both behead people.
Watermelons have short memories, which is why they are so prone to political and moral hypocrisy as they manifested yesterday. The Greens have forgotten how keen they were last year about the improvements in trade and diplomatic ties of the USA with another totalitarian relic: Cuba.

A 2009 report by Human Rights Watch concluded that
Raúl Castro has kept Cuba’s repressive machinery firmly in place…since being handed power by his brother Fidel Castro …[s]cores of political prisoners arrested under Fidel continue to languish in prison, and Raúl has used draconian laws and sham trials to incarcerate scores more who have dared to exercise their fundamental rights.
Freedom House classifies Cuba as being “Not Free” and notes that
Cuba is the only country in the Americas that consistently makes Freedom House’s list of the Worst of the Worst: the World’s Most Repressive Societies for widespread abuses of political rights and civil liberties.
Noam Chomsky once said the former Soviet Union was a dungeon with social services. Saudi Arabia is a dungeon with better social services than the Cuban dungeon. Saudi per capita income exceeds $50,000; Cuban per capita income is 1/5 of that.
In common with ISIS, a gang of thugs took over Cuba by military force in 1958 in the name of their god. Castro and his cronies murdered tens of thousands of political opponents both straight away and through the years to establish and retain their authority.
Cuba President Raul #Castro ratified its support to Venezuela against U.S. sanctions Fri at May Day parade in #Havana http://t.co/yqyF4XvcIA—
People's Daily,China (@PDChina) May 02, 2015
In common with Saudi Arabia after its foundation as a unified kingdom after the First World War, Cuba has become a hereditary monarchy that rules with an iron fist. In common with Saudi Arabia, Cuba is a haven for terrorists and a sponsor of terrorism abroad to this day.
The Green foreign affairs spokesman even went so far as to defend Westphalian sovereignty and the right of national self-determination and not to have ideologies imposed on a country.

and

The Saudi and Cuban dictatorships could not have put it better. The Russian communist dictatorship did go on about democracies not interfering in their internal affairs too.
The Green foreign affairs spokesman was so dewy eyed about the Cuban healthcare system after going to Cuba as a guest of their so-called parliament that it would make Michael Moore blush.

I wonder if the Greens would be so welcoming of Saudi foreign aid to the Pacific island health systems? Whatever else you can say about Saudi Arabia, they do have an excellent healthcare systems and plenty of petrodollars.
Saudi Arabia and Cuba are dungeons with Saudi Arabia having much better social services. New Zealand trades with both.
An unnamed co-conspirator in this fawning at the jackboots of a dictator even went so far as to say Cuba had its problems rather than speak truth to power and call it for what it is: a totalitarian dictatorship.

As the Greens said repeatedly regarding UN trade sanctions on Iraq after the first Gulf war, the only people that lose by limiting that trade were the ordinary people of that country were already on the end of a pretty bad deal.

That principle set out by the Greens regarding the harm of trade sanctions on ordinary people applies to trade with Cuba and Saudi Arabia as well. A country with trade links is more to lose than a country that does not have them. The ruling elite rarely suffers from trade sanctions as Daniel Griswold observed:
Even if sanctions inflict some pain on the target country, they typically fail because of the nature of regimes most likely to become targets of sanctions. Human rights abuses tend to vary inversely with economic development. Governments that systematically deprive citizens of basic human rights typically intervene in daily economic life, resulting in underdeveloped and relatively closed economies. Such nations are the least sensitive to economic pressure. The autocratic nature of their governments also means that they are relatively insulated from any domestic discontent caused by sanctions. If anything, sanctions tend to concentrate economic power in the hands of the target government and reduce that of citizens.
The Greens cannot welcome trade and diplomatic links with one totalitarian country but not another. The Greens cannot oppose trade sanctions on Iraq because of the harm to ordinary people then call for limits on trade ties with Saudi Arabia without regard to the harm to ordinary Saudis. Trade sanctions do not work in any case as Rogoff noted:
As Hufbauer and Schott, among others, have illustrated, the effects of sanctions are often fairly disappointing – so much so that many scholars have concluded that such measures often are imposed so that governments can appear to domestic audiences to be “doing something.” Certainly, severe US sanctions on Cuba failed to bring the Castro regime to heel; indeed, President Barack Obama’s move to reestablish full diplomatic relations may have more effect.
What makes each of these dungeons horrible is their totalitarian dictatorships, not the particular God that motivates their tyranny.
Taxpayers in every country should get one of these charts
29 Apr 2015 Leave a comment
in income redistribution, politics - Australia, politics - New Zealand, politics - USA, Public Choice, public economics, rentseeking Tags: public sector transparency
Tax summary: here's another honest/informative version of @hmtreasury chart by @StrongerInNos that explains "welfare" http://t.co/SeH9FJIRWq—
Jonathan Portes (@jdportes) November 02, 2014
New Zealand does an excellent job in attracting skilled migrants
29 Apr 2015 Leave a comment
in human capital, labour economics, labour supply, politics - Australia, politics - New Zealand, politics - USA Tags: economics of immigration
Migrants (esp. new ones) to UK more likely to have tertiary education than migrants to Australia [OECD[ http://t.co/xfOSQmiCxd—
Jonathan Portes (@jdportes) March 05, 2015
Housing unaffordability in New Zealand, 1988–2013
29 Apr 2015 Leave a comment
in politics - New Zealand, urban economics Tags: housing affordability, land supply, RMA, zoning
There has been a steady decline in housing affordability in New Zealand. The position is critical of the bottom 20% of the income ladder with now four in 10 of them spending more than 30% of their disposable income on housing costs in relatively good economic times.
via Statistics New Zealand, New Zealand Social Indicators, Housing affordability.
Would a living wage reduce poverty in America?
28 Apr 2015 Leave a comment
in labour economics, minimum wage, politics - Australia, politics - New Zealand, politics - USA, poverty and inequality Tags: labour demographics, living wage, poverty and inequality
New Zealand on a cloudless day
28 Apr 2015 Leave a comment
in politics - New Zealand Tags: New Zealand, space

HT: David Farrar via NASA captured this incredible shot of New Zealand under cloudless skies | Business Insider.


Recent Comments